Why do some people think that there is a fake 96,000-patient database that sank hydroxychloroquine? A fake patient database linked to a study published in the Lancet that was later retracted?

The usual suspects…
About the Fake 96,000-Patient Database That Sank Hydroxychloroquine
For a change, some of what they are talking about is actually true this time!
The Lancet study critical of hydroxychloroquine was retracted because it used data from Surgisphere that was unreliable and unverifiable.
“Interestingly, as the Lancet paper was retracted, the New England Journal of Medicine published the first randomized controlled clinical trial of hydroxychloroquine for prophylaxis against COVID-19, which turned out to be, unsurprisingly, entirely negative.”
The Surgisphere debacle
The Lancet study did not sink hydroxychloroquine as a treatment for COVID, though.
In addition to a negative paper in the New England Journal of Medicine a few weeks later, the independent RECOVERY trial stopped enrolling patients in its hydroxychloroquine arm because its results showed no clinical benefit.
And soon, the FDA revoked hydroxychloroquine's EUA, citing evidence including randomized trial results and excluding the retracted Lancet paper.
What else?
Many other studies found that hydroxychloroquine didn’t work, including:
the WHO Solidarity trial: Found no meaningful mortality benefit from hydroxychloroquine.
the NIH ORCHID trial: Found no additional benefit compared with placebo among hospitalized patients.
a Cochrane systematic review: Concluded hydroxychloroquine was not beneficial for hospitalized COVID-19 patients.
Of course, Maryanne Demasi doesn’t mention any of this in her article for the Brownstone Institute.
An article that is getting laundered across the social media accounts of popular anti-vaccine influencers who want you to think that sabotaging hydroxychloroquine helped get the COVID vaccine authorized.
Bottom line - The Lancet study was retracted on June 4, 2020, but independent randomized trials still found that hydroxychloroquine didn't work for COVID-19. And the FDA had already given hydroxychloroquine its own Emergency Use Authorization months earlier. There was a real scandal. As usual, there is no vaccine conspiracy, though.


